Welcome once again to another Friday Night Dice review. This time the hunt is on, not for Red October, but Captain Sonar.
Captain Sonar is a real-time anxiety attack simulator set thousands of leagues under the sea in a submarine. Published by Matagot, this game is very unique in its design. The basic premise is that 2 teams of up to 4 players, are aboard their own submarine (which you get to name). Tasked with destroying an enemy submarine piloted by another team. Doing so with teamwork, communication, and fast thinking.
Games last anywhere from 15 minutes to 45, it's all dependant on players. It is playable with 2-8 players depending on how you want to play it.
This game is playable in several configurations depending on the number of players on each team. I'm going to cover what I think is the most enjoyable, 2 Teams of 4 players.
So, this game is a bit more complicated than our last review. Within the teams of 4, each player picks a certain role on the submarine. These roles are either Captain, First Mate, Engineer, and Radio Operator. Each player will have a card at their station, along with a board pen, which they use to track and complete the tasks they need to operate the sub successfully. Let's break down each role.
The captain's card looks like this.
The captain's job is to steer the sub, and plot the best course of action based on the information he has. They must announce the directions they are moving the sub, which they draw on the map grid on their card. They talk to the first mate with regards to what systems they want charged, and the radio operator for information on where the enemy sub is. They also announce use of systems, such as sonar ping, torpedo launches, or silent running.
The position of Captain is challenging, due to needing to listen to all your team and make rapid decisions based on the information they give you. The rules specific to your role, are that you must announce your directions of travel clearly, and in the format of 'Move North'. This is to limit confusion for the radio operators. You cannot cross over your own path (kind of like the phone game snake). However, you can erase all your previous path by surfacing, which you also need to decide.
The First Mate's card looks like this.
The First mate, has the easiest job aboard the sub, which makes it ideal if you have a new player. Their job is every move the captain makes, they can put a point in a system. When that system has all the points in it, it's charged and ready to use. The first mate needs to communicate with the engineer, to make sure that system is currently working, and with the captain to tell them it's working and ready to use. They can also act well as a relay of information between the captain and engineer when things get hectic (they always do). The first mate also tracks the sub's hit points, and when it takes damage.
Let's use this time to have a look at each of the systems you might be charging. They're divided into 3 systems, Red/Weapons, Green/Locating, Yellow/Misc.
Torpedo and mines are your weapons. Once charged you can shoot a torpedo over a range of 4 grid dots at a target announced by the captain. It deals 2 damage if the enemy was on that exact grid, and 1 damage if they were in a dot adjacent to the target one.
Mines deal the same damage; however, you drop them on whatever grid you are on when you use them. However! All you do is announce that you've dropped one, not where. So, they can be handy later if your enemy has lost track of them.
Drones and sonar are how you locate the enemy sub. Launching a drone involves your captain asking if the sub is in one of the bigger numbered sections of the map ,1-9. The enemy captain then must truthfully respond.
Sonar is again used by the captain, however this time the enemy captain gives you two pieces of info regarding their locations, but one of them is false.
Silent running and scenario make up the last two systems. Silent running let's you move 4 grid dots in a straight line, unannounced, making it crucial for escaping the enemy.
Scenario is for a specific advanced map, littered with mines, which either team can sue at any time if this system is charged.
The Engineer's card looks like this.
The engineer, is the most stressful job on the whole team. I highly recommend putting your most experienced player in this role. Or if you're all playing this for the first time, your most level-headed friend.
The engineer's job is what makes Captain Sonar a game. With each move that the captain makes, they must 'break' a system in the corresponding box with the direction moved by the captain.
Certain systems are linked over multiple boxes, if you break every system in one of those chains, the problem clears, and they become fixed. So, it's in your best interest to communicate what directions would be beneficial ahead of time to your captain (you can see how this might become stressful right?).
There are also systems not linked by chains, if you choose to break one of these they are broken indefinitely until you surface, at which point all systems are fixed. There are also radioactive symbols pertaining to the sub's core. These are scattered over all direction boxes, and if you accidentally break them all, the ship takes 1 hit point of damage. You also cause the ship to take 1 hit point of damage, if you break all the systems in one direction box.
As the engineer you are the crux of how quickly and successfully the sub can manoeuvre and operate, and you need to be on point with the info you give out to the first mate. As well as being the only person on the ship who can directly hurt the sub itself, you can see why the pressure is so high.
The Radio Operator's card looks like this.
The radio operator has a fairly stressful job. Their job is to listen to the directions given by the enemy captain, and using a see-through overlay, try to track where the enemy sub is on the map.
Since the subs can't move through land masses, and are obviously bound to the edges of the map, this becomes easier as the game goes on.
Since there are only so many places where your snake-like drawing will fit right? Wrong.
Remember any time the enemy team surface, their captain will clear their previous path, and be able to go over previous coordinates. You must also communicate with captain about where you think the enemy sub is so he can accurately fire torpedoes.
The rub in Captain Sonar is two-fold. You've heard me mention surfacing a few times so far, let's delve into what that means. Surfacing allows the captain to clear his path travelled, allowing him more movement options. It also allows the engineer and first mate to clear their cards and start a fresh with nothing broken or charged.
To surface, the captain shouts 'surface!' the entire team downs pens, and proceeds to one at a time, draw around the picture of the sub on the engineer's card. You must do this one at a time, and you can't go outside the lines. Once completed, you show this to the enemy engineer and they must confirm than no one messed up the line drawing.
What are the enemy team doing whilst this happens? LITERALLY ANYTHING!! You guys have downed tools, and are literally sitting ducks, and the enemy team can carry on business as usual. Meanwhile your poor radio operator has to go full savant and remember all the moves taken by the enemy captain without being able to write them down, and draw in his part of the sub. Then play catch up once you guys can dive again.
The best part about Captain Sonar, is that everything I have mentioned, happens ALL AT ONCE! Your movement and lethality are only limited by the skill and communication of your team. As you can imagine, when you have a bead on the enemy and score a direct hit and are keen to go for the jugular, it gets rowdy. Not a time you want to hear that the torpedoes are broken, just as the enemy are firing up silent running.
This makes for knife edge tension and amazingly addictive satisfaction when you pull it together and coordinate well. It also makes for hilarious conflict when things go pear shaped.
I love Captain Sonar, it really sold board games as a whole for me, just by being SO unique. Having come from a world of video games, I never really thought you could get similar tension levels in a game medium that wasn't electronic. I was very happily wrong. It seemed thoroughly enjoyed by everyone who came down, and we played 6-7 games of it.
Is new person friendly, however gets very stressful. Probably not recommended for people brand new to board games, however if keen to sink or swim they should have at it.
Welcome one and all to the inaugural FND review. Essentially a group of friends and I play games every Friday, and I've decided to turn our thoughts and experience into a pseudo board game review series. I say pseudo, because none of us have reviewed board games before, or generally know what's going on at any point in time. With that said, let's begin.
Munchkin deluxe is one of the numerous variants on the card game Munchkin. What sets this version apart, is that it comes with a board and character figures to keep track of as you play. Where the original version was merely a card only game.
The basic premise of the game is to kill monsters, gather treasure, and ascend in hero levels until level 10. At which point you win the game. It plays 3-6 players, and games last between 1 and 2 hours.
The rules are easy to grasp, and even encourage you to test, or sometimes even ignore them if merited. Gameplay proceeds by the player kicking down a door in the dungeon, fighting a monster if you draw one from the 'Door' deck, then claiming it's bounty and advancing to the next room. Which also progresses your level.
You don't always get a monster, irritating and hilarious alternatives await. You could be cursed, or granted a boon. If that's the case, you may choose to fight a monster card you already posses or loot the room. Which allows to draw another Door card, however unlike when you kick the door down, you may draw this card face down rather than having everyone see it.
After your turn has concluded, regardless of monsters slain, if you exceed the card limit you must donate them to the lowest level player. If there are multiple of them, you split them and decide who gets the bigger half.
The crux of Munchkin, is the player interaction. The fact that only one person can win, doesn't really start to play into it until people get to level 6+. The game itself allows for aiding other people in fighting their monsters, as well as interfering and royally screwing over player's fights also.
Everyone starts off friendly, helping each other, donating equipment others may find useful that you can't use, maybe even passing on treasure gained from helping someone. Then the penny drops, and so begins the real game. Trying to bribe, back stab, and generally deceive your way to victory. The main constraint on winning, is that you MUST kill a monster to reach level 10. So, obviously you're going to be heavily hindered by everyone else, come your attempt. You must scheme accordingly.
Ideally you amass enough back up plans to thwart any potential reckoning when the time comes. This normally means having an out against curses, and definitely enough items to power your character up to at least level 20+.
Munchkin Deluxe is a good game, it has everything a fun game needs. Pleasing aesthetic, a fun premise, easy to pick up, and most importantly player conflict. However, it's replay ability is mildly limited. The general game flow will come to a head, as someone attempts to gain level 10. Normally they will be thwarted by the co-opted efforts of everyone else. Then when the next highest person comes to try their luck, people generally don't have enough cards to stop them, and they win.
This problem may be changed depending on group size, we only played with 4 people. Or possibly with one of the many expansions.
Regardless, it's a solid game and very much worth your time. Easy to pick and play, hilarious, maybe too long duration for very new people.